A Comprehensive Guide to Selecting the Best Virtual Table Top (VTT) for Live Tabletop Gaming Maps
Virtual Table Top (VTT) software has become an indispensable aid for tabletop gaming, especially during the pandemic. With so many options available, choosing the right one can be overwhelming. In this article, we will explore the advantages and disadvantages of various popular VTT platforms, with a focus on their capabilities in sharing live tabletop gaming maps.
Introduction to Virtual Table Top (VTT) Software
A Virtual Table Top (VTT) is a digital tool designed to facilitate tabletop gaming over the internet. These platforms allow players and Dungeon Masters (DMs) to visualize and interact with game maps, characters, and narrative elements in real-time. VTTs have become increasingly popular as they provide convenience, accessibility, and enhanced immersion for tabletop gaming sessions.
The Most Popular VTT Platforms
Roll20
Overview: Roll20 is one of the most widely used VTT platforms, known for its browser-based accessibility. Players and DMs can join sessions without any setup or installation, making it user-friendly for beginners.
Strengths: Roll20 supports a vast range of game systems, including virtually any role-playing game (RPG) system. It offers a wide array of customization options and a large community of users.
Weaknesses: While Roll20 is user-friendly, it can be challenging for DMs to automate specific in-game functionalities due to its learning curve. Additionally, the required subscription for DMs can be costly, and token packs and other assets come at a premium.
Fantasy Grounds (FG)
Overview: Fantasy Grounds is renowned for its automation capabilities, allowing DMs to focus more on storytelling. The platform offers a seamless experience with integrated visual effects and automated rule mechanics.
Strengths: FG is highly automated, making it easier for DMs to run games smoothly. It supports a broad range of games and offers free resources for beginners, including Fantasy Grounds College.
Weaknesses: The learning curve for both DMs and players is steep, requiring dedicated time and effort to become proficient. While players can use free versions, they need to download and install the software, which may be inconvenient. Moreover, the cost of a DM license can be prohibitive, and WotC assets are generally cheaper on FG compared to other platforms.
Astral
Overview: Astral is a newer VTT platform that gained popularity for its dynamic mapping feature, which integrates visual effects. It is browser-based and even offers a mobile version, making it highly versatile.
Strengths: Astral's dynamic mapping and integrated visual effects provide a visually stunning experience. It is straightforward to use, especially for mapping. The user community is passionate, and those who use it swear by its effectiveness.
Weaknesses: Given its smaller user base, there is limited resources and support available. Additionally, while character and game mechanics automation is minimal, Astral is not fully compatible with all game systems, particularly those not mainstream.
Foundry Virtual Tabletop (VTT)
Overview: Foundry VTT is known for its flexibility and modularity. It is highly customizable thanks to APIs and modding tools that enable community development.
Strengths: Foundry VTT offers unparalleled customization options, allowing DMs to tailor the platform to their specific needs. It is an open platform that integrates well with third-party tools, including DD Beyond, for character creation and game management.
Weaknesses: While highly customizable, Foundry VTT can be complex for beginners. The integration of WotC books and assets is limited, and the user base is relatively small, which may limit the availability of resources and support.
Comparison of VTT Platforms
Each VTT platform has its strengths and weaknesses. Roll20 offers the widest range of game system support and browser-based accessibility, but with a higher learning curve and cost for DMs. Fantasy Grounds excels in automation and game system compatibility but requires more initial investment. Astral provides dynamic mapping and visual effects, though its limited user base may mean fewer resources are available. Foundry VTT is the most customizable yet complex to set up, offering integration with third-party tools but limited support for WotC assets.
Conclusion
Choosing the best VTT for live tabletop gaming maps depends largely on your specific needs and preferences. Fantasy Grounds has become my preferred choice, but the ideal platform may vary from one DM to another. Experimenting with different platforms is recommended to find the one that fits your gaming style and requirements.
Remember, no matter which VTT platform you choose, the key to a successful game session lies in the creative and narrative focus of your DM and the engagement of your players. Happy gaming!