Aunt Marge's Reaction to Harry and Dudley Discovering Their Wizarding Heritage: An Alternate Universe Scenario
In an alternate universe where Harry Potter and Dudley Dursley are both wizards, Aunt Marge's reaction would likely be a complex mix of emotions driven by her character traits, family dynamics, and social expectations. Let us delve into these reactions through the lens of Aunt Marge's unique perspective.
Disbelief and Denial
Initially, Marge might refuse to believe that Harry could be a wizard, given her long-standing disdain for him. In her mind, she might attribute any magical occurrences to trickery or misbehavior on Harry's part. This denial would indicate her inability to reconcile the fact that her beloved niece, Petunia, might have passed on her similar loathing for magic.
Unwavering Favoritism Towards Dudley
Upon learning that Dudley is a wizard, Marge would likely react more positively towards him. She might indulge him with praise or gifts, sincerely viewing his magical abilities as a reflection of her own value as a family member. This favoritism stems from her deep-seated need for Dudley to excel, a common theme in the Dursley family dynamics. However, her actions would be aimed at elevating Dudley's status above Harry's.
Contempt for Harry and Desire to Maintain Social Status
Marge's contempt for Harry would only intensify if he were revealed to be a wizard. She might accuse him of being a trickster or a troublemaker, seemingly justifying her long-standing animosity. The idea of wizards in the family could lead her to worry about how it would affect the Dursley reputation. Thus, she would likely attempt to distance herself from Harry, insisting that Dudley only use his powers in a way that reflects well on the family. This strategy would be in line with her desire to maintain a certain image in society and to appear as a respectable and knowledgeable figure.
Domineering Personality and Attempts to Control the Situation
Given her domineering personality, Marge would probably try to exert control over both Harry and Dudley. She might attempt to dictate how they should behave as wizards, envisioning herself as the authority figure. She could set strict rules and guidelines for their magical conduct, ensuring that her influence over them remains unchallenged. However, this control would only fuel the tension and resentment between Harry and Marge, potentially leading to further conflicts and strained relationships.
Considering the Dursley Family's Evolution in the Deathly Hallows
While it is true that the Dursley family, particularly Harry, experience a significant shift towards a more positive and loving relationship in The Deathly Hallows, Marge would not benefit from these advancements due to her character traits. Her relationship with Harry remains unwaveringly negative, and the Dursleys' changed stance would have little impact on her. Therefore, she would not show any sympathy for Harry, and would likely be even more cruel in response to his wizarding abilities.
Conclusion
In summary, Aunt Marge's reaction to both Harry and Dudley discovering their wizarding heritage would be driven by her character traits, family dynamics, and social expectations. Initially, she would deny the possibility of Harry being a wizard, favoring Dudley's newfound abilities, expressing contempt for Harry, and attempting to control their magical conduct. Despite any potential negative impacts on the family's reputation, Marge would prioritize her own satisfaction and the perceived elevation of Dudley's status.