Choosing the Right University for Composition: Kings College London vs Goldsmiths University of London
When it comes to choosing a university for composition, the decision can be quite daunting. While personal experiences and recommendations can provide valuable insights, it is crucial to conduct a thorough research and analysis to make the best choice for yourself. In this article, we will explore the strengths and weaknesses of both Kings College London and Goldsmiths University of London, focusing on their composition departments and the faculty members who will guide your studies.
Unbiased Analysis: Choosing the Best Fit for You
The decision between Kings College London and Goldsmiths University of London for composition largely depends on your personal goals, style of music, and how you wish to approach your studies. It is important to look beyond the institution and focus on the staff responsible for composition. The composition faculty at each university has unique strengths and areas of expertise, which may better suit your aspirations and interests.
Differences in Composition Faculty and Specializations
At universities and conservatoires, there are often specific specializations and "slants" that individual faculties might focus on. At Kings College London, the primary composition teacher is George Benjamin, a prominent figure in the contemporary music scene. George Benjamin's background includes studying with Sir Harrison Birtwistle, a noted composer. Furthermore, his own education includes studying with Olivier Messiaen, a highly respected and influential composer. This background adds significant value and depth to his teaching approach, making him a compelling choice for those interested in avant-garde and modern composition.
At Goldsmiths University of London, the primary composition teacher is Roger Redgate. However, there is a notable gap in the credentials and experience of Roger Redgate when compared to George Benjamin. Redgate's resume includes work in film and TV, jazz, and improvisation, but I could not find any high-level educational credentials or notable teachers associated with him. While these areas of expertise are certainly valuable, they may not align as closely with the traditional composition studies that many students seek.
Personal Musical Preferences Matter
Whether you are a minimalist composer or a fan of avant-garde music, your choice of university should reflect your personal interests and style. If your music aligns with Brian Ferneyhough's style, you would likely benefit from a teacher who is sympathetic to that approach. Conversely, if you are more interested in minimalist compositions, it would be more suitable to seek a teacher with a strong background in minimalist techniques.
Focus on finding a teacher who can help you develop your unique musical voice and style while providing the necessary guidance and support. This is truly the most important factor in your overall success as a composition student.
Research Your Options Thoroughly
When evaluating universities for composition, it is crucial to research extensively. Look into the specific courses offered, the composition faculty members, and the historical contributions of each department. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each institution will help you make an informed decision that aligns with your goals and aspirations.
Whichever university you choose, the most important aspect is your teacher. Both Kings College London and Goldsmiths University of London have strong composition programs, but the personal connection and guidance you receive from your teacher will be pivotal in shaping your musical journey.
Good luck with your decision and your musical endeavors!