Opposing Views on the Founding of the United States
The debate over whether the United States of America was founded on European culture or not is a contentious one. Some argue that it is without question a European creation, while others see it as an entirely separate entity with its roots in native Armenian, Arabian, and Iranian knowledge. This article aims to explore this topic by examining various viewpoints and the historical context that shaped the formation of the USA.
The United States Was Founded on European Culture
Supporters of the idea that the United States of America was founded on European culture argue that its establishment and political ideology were heavily influenced by European traditions. This includes both the English political heritage and the Scottish Enlightenment. The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution by Bernard Bailyn and The Cousins' Wars by Kevin Phillips are cited as seminal works that delve into these foundational principles.
Additionally, the principles enshrined in the US Constitution are believed to be largely derived from European law and the thoughts of European philosophers. While the United States has undoubtedly grown to include people from many parts of the world, its original constitution and governmental structure are rooted in European traditions.
The U.S. Was Founded Independently of European Influence
On the other side of the debate, there are those who argue that the United States created itself independently. For instance, it was not European colonialism that created the United States, but rather the American colonists who fought for their freedom and established their own nation. The United States was not a direct result of European creation but a product of the colonists' desire for self-governance.
The foundation of the United States lies in the ideas of people who lived and fought for their rights on this land. The Constitution and the principles it contains were created by the members of the Continental Congress, and the war for independence was waged by the American people, not by European powers.
The Role of European Immigrants in Shaping the U.S.
Another perspective combines both viewpoints. It acknowledges the European influence on the founding of the United States, but also highlights the significant role played by European immigrants in shaping the country's development. Immigration has been a defining factor in the U.S. history, and while the initial structure and principles were European, the diverse population has contributed to the rich cultural tapestry of the nation.
Europeans, particularly those from England, Scotland, Ireland, and Germany, came to America in large numbers during the colonial period. They brought with them their beliefs, traditions, and aspirations, albeit not always in a benign or ethical manner. Some were treated with contempt and oppression, as the quote suggests, which highlights the complex history of colonialism and its aftermath.
Conclusion: A Complex Blend of Influences
The debate over whether the United States of America was founded on European culture is a nuanced one. While it is true that European culture and traditions played a significant role in shaping the early foundation of the United States, it is also evident that the country developed independently and grew to encompass a diverse array of influences and identities.
The United States is a product of both the European heritage it inherited and the indigenous knowledge that predated it. It is a nation of immigrants, founded by people from various backgrounds who worked together to build a prosperous and free nation. Understanding this complex blend of influences is essential to comprehending the true nature of the United States of America.