Is Rosanna Miller Really Amish?
From what I have heard, most of the show is fake. But she has gone back to her family if that helps you any. To be honest, I have never met any real Amish that believe acting is acceptable.
Who is Rosanna Miller?
Rosanna Miller is a member of the Old Order Amish, which is the most traditional form of the Amish religion. Her journey is documented in the show Return to Amish, which began filming in early 2020. She was eighteen years old when the show started, and it has garnered a lot of attention and controversy for its portrayal of the Amish lifestyle.
The Old Order Amish
The Old Order Amish is a subset of the Amish community that strictly adheres to a traditional lifestyle that includes minimal use of modern technology and rejected education beyond the eighth grade. They seek to live in harmony with the Bible and to avoid the world of commercialism and secularism. This lifestyle is characterized by simple living, plain clothes, and a strong emphasis on community and family.
Life in the Amish Community
Rosanna grew up in Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania, a town with a large Amish population. Amish communities typically consist of a dense network of extended family and friends, and for most of the Amish, life revolves around farming and other agricultural pursuits. They do not use telephones, electricity, or automobiles, relying instead on horse-drawn buggies and manual labor. There is a strong emphasis on family, community, and spiritual devotion.
The Controversy
The show Return to Amish has stirred a lot of debate about the authenticity of the Amish lifestyle. While Rosanna claims to have gone back to her family and follows the values of the Amish community, some viewers and critics wonder if this is truly the case. The show often seems to depict a version of the Amish community that may be staged or exaggerated for the sake of entertainment.
Real Amish Values and Beliefs
From personal experience, most real Amish are very wary of television and the broader influence of the outside world on their children. They believe that the Wolf of Wall Street and other such shows portray a life that is not consistent with their values and desires for their children. Acting is often seen as a morally dubious activity, given the emphasis on truth and honesty in Amish communities.
Conclusion
To sum up, while Rosanna Miller identifies as a member of the Old Order Amish and has clearly embraced the lifestyle and values of the Amish community, the authenticity of the show remains a subject of debate. It is important to remember that the Amish, like any community, are complex and multifaceted. The true heart of Amish life lies in its deep commitment to faith, family, and tradition, but it is up to individuals like Rosanna to navigate this framework of beliefs and practices.