Understandings and Perspectives of Indian Punjabis on Pakistani Punjabis
As the first generation descendant of a migrant from Pakistani Punjab, I feel qualified to contribute to this discussion about the relationship and perspectives between Indian and Pakistani Punjabis. My parents migrated to India from Pakistani Punjab in their teens, and while I was born in India 30 years after the partition, I have intimate knowledge of the atrocities and horrors that were inflicted upon non-Muslims, particularly in the western Punjab and Sindh provinces of Pakistan.
The tales I heard from my parents, and later my own experiences, paint a picture of deep-seated hatred and trauma. However, when it comes to everyday life and cultural practices, the differences between Punjabis on both sides of the border are minimal. Apart from religious faith, there is a profound connection that binds us together. Our shared language, traditions, and spirit are a testament to our cultural continuity.
Indian Punjabis and Pakistani Punjabis share a rich cultural heritage that predates the partition of 1947. The Punjabi language, for instance, is the same on both sides of the border. You'll find people speaking dialects such as Multani Jhaangi and other languages similar to Punjabi in both regions. Similarly, the love for non-veg, a once-taboo cuisine, has crossed borders. Our ladies embrace the traditional clothing styles, and common surnames like Bajwa, Choudhari, Malik, and Gill are prevalent in both Punjabs.
Similarities and Diversity
Despite our many similarities, the partition has created a significant chasm. Indian Punjabis do not necessarily harbor feelings of animosity towards Pakistani Punjabis. In fact, many of us wonder why we are so divided, given the great undivided state of Punjab before 1947. The real differences lie not in our shared heritage, but in the circumstances created by the partition and subsequent political developments.
Religious and Cultural Differences
Interestingly, Indian Punjabis and Pakistani Punjabis share a strong sense of identity rooted in our religious and cultural traditions. While religion has indeed become a dividing factor, it is not all-encompassing. For many, the shared Punjabi identity transcends religious differences. Both regions have similar festivals like Vaisakhi, Holi, and Diwali, which are celebrated with equal enthusiasm and fervor.
Challenges and Misconceptions
Despite the similarities, there are valid reasons for the tensions between the two communities. For example, incidents like the murder attempts on individuals and atrocities committed by certain individuals or groups in the past can understandably lead to feelings of mistrust and animosity. However, it is essential to understand that such incidents do not represent the entire community. Many individuals from both sides share a deep understanding of the complexities and challenges faced post-partition.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the question of how Indian Punjabis view Pakistani Punjabis is multifaceted. While we may have a shared cultural and linguist heritage, the legacy of partition and political tensions has created a divide. For many, the desire to bridge this gap and honor our common roots remains a priority. The bond that ties Punjabis together extends beyond borders, and it is our shared history that should guide us toward a more united and peaceful future.