Sansa Stark’s Policy on Refugees: A Misunderstanding of Her Character

Sansa Stark, a beloved character in the series A Song of Ice and Fire, has faced scrutiny and criticism for her decisions surrounding refugees. Several points often misconstrued about Sansa's stance on foreigners have led to the misunderstanding that she dislikes and distrusts them without any genuine reason. In this article, we will delve into her true motivations and actions during the episode where she insists that Yohn Royce keep the gates open for refugees.

Dislike and Trust in Sansa Stark

It is important to clarify that Sansa does not inherently dislike foreigners. The Vale, where Sansa is from, are Andals, and they are considered foreigners to a Northwoman like her, yet they are her strongest supporters. The North has long fought against the Free Folk, a group that also includes Dothraki and Unsullied mercenaries, yet in Season 6, Sansa proudly proclaims them as “her army.”

Sansa's dislike and distrust of Daenerys Targaryen stems from more than just their origins. Daenerys promised to conquer the North, a region that had recently achieved its independence, which posed a significant threat to its autonomy. Additionally, Daenerys imprisoned Jon Snow, Lord of Dragonstone and the North's heir, on Dragonstone for months without a trial or due process. These actions deeply compromised the trust Sansa had built with Jon and ultimately with the inhabitants of the North.

Container for Refugees: A Practical Necessity

The insistence that Yohn Royce keep the gates open for refugees, specifically Northmen fleeing the impending battle with the Army of the Dead, is a practical necessity, not a reflection of distrust. The refugees in question are not foreigners but her own people seeking the safety of Winterfell as they face an apocalyptic battle. Sansa’s decision to allow them to enter shows her understanding of the dire situation and her commitment to protect her people.

Dismissing Nonsensical Claims

There are those who attempt to glorify Daenerys Targaryen's actions through hypothetical anecdotes or dismissSansa's concerns as baseless. However, this is a transparent attempt to neutralize any criticism against Daenerys. In reality, Sansa’s concerns have specific and rational bases. Her problem with Daenerys is rooted in the promised conquest of the North and the unjust imprisonment of Jon, rather than any animosity towards their origins.

Welcoming vs. Distrust

Sansa is not hostile towards the Dothraki or Unsullied; in fact, she has shown a certain level of trust and tolerance. She recognizes that the Dothraki, known as brutal raiders, have played a crucial role in defending Winterfell and the survivors of the campaign against the Dead. Her actions, such as allowing refugees to enter and acknowledging the importance of their allies, reflect a pragmatic approach rather than distrust.

A Critique of Anonymous Attacks

Anonymous questions and critiques that seek to tarnish Sansa's character through half-truths and baseless accusations are often unwarranted and insensitive. If one truly wants to debate the characters of A Song of Ice and Fire, it is important to engage in respectful and informed discourse. Delving into the complexities of Sansa's decisions and motivations, as showcased in her strategic and compassionate handling of the refugees, provides a more nuanced and accurate portrayal of her character.

In conclusion, Sansa Stark's insistence that Yohn Royce keep the gates open for refugees is a logical and understandable response to the immediate threat of the Army of the Dead. Her actions, contrary to the misconceptions, reflect a deep regard for her people and a strategic understanding of the dangers they face. It is crucial to critically evaluate these actions rather than allowing unsupported claims to define her character.