The Myth of the 'Special Relationship' Between the USA and UK: A Closer Look
Often romanticized and mythologized, the so-called 'special relationship' between the United States (USA) and the United Kingdom (UK) is not as special or influential as popular belief would suggest. This relationship has long been a topic of debate and analysis, with many questioning its true nature and impact.
No Special Bond
Firstly, it is important to note that the USA is not particularly concerned with the UK. There is no actual 'special relationship' because it is difficult to have a genuine relationship when one party is indifferent to the other. This indifference is a key reason why no formal trade deal exists between the two nations, and why the military alliance includes virtually all of Europe, with the USA being the senior party.
Only Photo Ops and Symbolic gestures
The manifestation of this relationship is minimal. As of now, there is no trade deal with Washington or any in the works. The only tangible aspects of their relationship include a military alliance and a global security monitoring system, but even these include other countries. These relationships are predominantly symbolic and aimed at maintaining a perception in the UK, especially among the Tory and English elite, that the country remains a significant global power.
A Delusion with Consequences
Renewing the 'special relationship' delusion is dangerous. Apart from a few military adventures, the UK has often been seen as a tag-along nation in US military operations since 1945. While the UK contributes contingents to these operations, it rarely has a decisive say in the strategy or outcomes.
Advantages and Disadvantages
The myth of the 'special relationship' has its advantages. The USA allows the use of the English language free of charge, and in return, the UK allows certain individuals who might not sit well with American public opinion to live in California, such as James Corden and Prince Harry. However, it is worth questioning whether this arrangement is truly beneficial and whether there are better alliances to focus on, such as those with Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and the Commonwealth, where there is a genuine affinity and mutual interest.
The Invention of a Myth
Furthermore, the origin of the term 'special relationship' is not what it is made out to be. It was invented by the Daily Express in 1941 to boost British morale during World War II. Since then, the term has been used to justify a variety of relationships and policies that have little to do with a true special bond.
Independence and Mutual Respect
Both nations are independent and operate on their own terms. They cooperate on defense and other areas, but the USA is no more likely to introduce UK gun control, and the UK is no more likely to adopt US healthcare systems. The conduct of former British Prime Minister Tony Blair during his tenure, especially his close alignment with the USA during the Iraq War, did not endear him to the British public, highlighting the complexities and sometimes disagreements between the two nations.
The idea of a 'special relationship' has often been used to obscure the fact that the UK and USA have a more pragmatic and often complicated relationship based on realpolitik and practical interests rather than an inherent bond. Understanding the nuances of their relationship is crucial for both nations and those observing their interactions.